The Riyadh criminal court found Esther Wanja Muthoni guilty of sex outside marriage last month, sentencing the domestic worker to 100 lashes and a one-year ban from the kingdom, according to reports by The Guardian and The New York Times. Muthoni, who worked as a housekeeper and nanny, became pregnant after a brief relationship with an Egyptian man and gave birth to a son named Abudy. She has been unable to leave Saudi Arabia for more than a year as a result of the legal case while her five children remain in Kenya.
International rights groups have condemned the ruling. Maryam Aldossari, acting director at ALQST, said the sentence constituted an act of violence and that the woman should have been sent back to Kenya instead of being punished. Aldossari told The Guardian that the decision highlighted inconsistencies in Saudi Arabia’s reform narrative under Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who has sought to present the kingdom as a modern state that empowers women.
Ekaterina Porras Sivolobova, founder of the migrant rights group Do Bold, described the punishment as targeting vulnerable women and stripping a mother of her dignity. She noted that hospitals in Saudi Arabia are required to report cases of unmarried women giving birth to authorities, which is how Muthoni’s case came to light. Many other women avoid detection by giving birth at home, Porras Sivolobova added in comments reported by The Guardian.
The ruling relies on an orthodox interpretation of Islamic law that prescribes 100 lashes for sex outside marriage, a crime under the Saudi system that disproportionately affects women, according to rights groups. The court did not indicate any action against the child’s father, The New York Times reported. Saudi authorities announced significant curbs to corporal punishment in 2020 but cases continue to surface.
Human Rights Watch data places the number of migrant workers in Saudi Arabia at more than 13 million, a large number of whom are domestic staff from countries including Kenya. The kafala sponsorship system ties workers to their employers, limiting their ability to change jobs or leave the country without permission despite some reforms. The case has raised fresh questions about protections for female migrant workers in the kingdom.
Muthoni told The New York Times she does not deserve the punishment and fears she will not be able to endure the lashes. The mother of five chose not to appeal the verdict in the hope it would expedite her return to her children in Kenya. The development follows the recent postponement of a planned visit to Saudi Arabia by the UN special rapporteur on violence against women and girls Reem Alsalem.
ع