ع
The Dubai Civil Court of First Instance ruled that a pediatrician and the hospital where he practices must jointly pay Dh350,000 in compensation to the infant’s father after determining that the doctor failed to undertake necessary diagnostic examinations and clinical monitoring for a premature baby experiencing respiratory distress, Emirates 24|7 reported. The child was born at 34 weeks gestation by caesarean section and required immediate intensive care due to breathing difficulties, with the family returning to the hospital on several occasions as symptoms persisted. Court records show the baby’s condition then deteriorated rapidly, prompting emergency transfer to a different facility where he arrived suffering from cyanosis and critical oxygen deprivation but was resuscitated in time.
According to the same report, the Supreme Committee for Medical Liability concluded that the treatment deviated from accepted medical standards for premature infants with respiratory issues, a determination the court fully adopted in establishing liability. The father argued in his suit that repeated visits should have triggered more thorough intervention to prevent the life-threatening episode that followed. This case highlights the role of expert medical panels in informing judicial outcomes on clinical negligence claims.
Emirates 24|7 reported that the Supreme Committee for Medical Liability’s findings proved central to the verdict, confirming that standard protocols for diagnostic assessment and ongoing observation had not been followed. The infant’s initial admission to intensive care after birth underscored the vulnerability of his condition, yet follow-up care at the first hospital fell short. The compensation award accounts for the harm inflicted on the child and the distress experienced by his family.
A Supreme Committee for Medical Liability review covering recent years documented a sharp decline in medical liability complaints, falling from 651 in 2021 to 292 in 2025 as healthcare standards across the UAE improved. The committee, formed under a 2012 Cabinet resolution, comprises 22 specialist consultants drawn from all major health authorities and issues binding decisions on appeals from initial medical reports. Its assessments carry decisive weight in civil court proceedings involving allegations of error.
Committee figures place dentistry at the top of confirmed errors in 2025 with 32 percent of cases, followed by obstetrics and gynecology at 19 percent, though pediatric matters also feature among reviewed specialties. The drop in complaints has been linked to stricter professional oversight and the introduction of a filing fee designed to deter unsubstantiated claims. UAE health regulators continue to emphasize training and protocol adherence to further reduce such incidents in neonatal and pediatric care.
The Dubai court’s decision aligns with a broader framework under which the Supreme Committee for Medical Liability serves as the final arbiter on technical questions of medical fault, with its reports inadmissible to further challenge in the courts. In this instance the panel’s report directly supported the finding of negligence in the management of a high-risk premature newborn. The awarded sum addresses both tangible losses and the emotional toll on the family following the ordeal.
